New Jersey's Power Prices Jumped 7.9%. Massachusetts Didn't Budge. Here's What the Gap Means for Your Business


Two states, one region, two completely different electric bills. New Jersey residential power prices averaged 24.09 cents per kilowatt-hour in January–August 2026, up 7.9% from the same period last year. Massachusetts averaged 30.19 cents — essentially flat, down a tenth of a percent. The national average rose 6.8% to 18.19 cents.
Read that again: the state whose prices jumped is still the cheaper of the two by more than six cents a kilowatt-hour. Massachusetts households are paying about 66% more than the national average, and New Jersey households about 32% more. The gap between the two states is the story — and for commercial and industrial buyers, it is a warning about where the next increases are coming from.
The Numbers
The data come from the U.S. Energy Information Administration's Electric Power Monthly,
covering average residential retail prices for January–August 2026 versus the same period in 2025. The figures are preliminary, but the pattern is unmistakable.
New Jersey: 24.09¢/kWh, up from 22.32¢ — +7.9%
Massachusetts: 30.19¢/kWh, down from 30.21¢ — −0.1%
United States: 18.19¢/kWh, up from 17.03¢ — +6.8%
At 900 kWh a month — the EIA's standard household benchmark — the New Jersey increase works out to roughly $16 more a month, about $191 a year, at the same usage. The Massachusetts household pays about $2 less a year. Nationally, the average household is on track to pay about $125 more a year, and the EIA's September outlook put the
average summer monthly bill at $196, up from $185 last year.
The neighbors tell the same uneven story. New York is up 12.1% to 29.26¢, Pennsylvania up 12.0% to 21.13¢, Maryland up 12.6% to 21.31¢, and Delaware up 7.1% to 17.98¢. In New England, Connecticut actually fell 9.1% to 27.47¢, Rhode Island held flat at 29.05¢, while Maine jumped 10.0% to 30.23¢ and New Hampshire surged 15.0% to 26.91¢. Only
four states in the country now average more than 30 cents: Hawaii (46.41¢), California (32.58¢), Maine (30.23¢), and Massachusetts (30.19¢).
Why New Jersey Jumped
New Jersey's 7.9% is not a mystery. It is the aftershock of the PJM capacity market.
In July 2024, PJM's capacity auction for the 2025/26 delivery year cleared at $269.92 per megawatt-day — up from $28.92 two years earlier, a more than ninefold increase. Those capacity costs flow straight into the supply charge on New Jersey bills through the state's Basic Generation Service (BGS) auction. When the new BGS rates took effect on June 1, 2025, typical residential bills rose roughly 17–20%, depending on the utility.
The January–August 2026 average captures that shock in full: every month of 2026 is priced off the post-June-2025 rates, while the 2025 comparison period still includes five months at the old, lower rates. That is why the year-over-year figure reads 7.9% rather than the full
17–20% — the increase is real; it is just spread across the comparison window.
The February 2026 BGS auction, certified by the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities, was calmer only because of a guardrail. After New Jersey and other PJM states pressed federal regulators, a temporary price collar capped capacity prices at $325 per megawatt-day (with a
$175 floor). June 1, 2026 changes were small: PSE&G down 1.8%, JCP&L up 1.6%, Atlantic City Electric up 0.1%, Rockland Electric down 0.7%. The collar held the line — but it did not bring prices back down.
And the pressure is not gone. PJM's July 2026 capacity auction for the 2028/29 delivery year cleared at the $325 cap, and the procured capacity fell 6,831 MW short of the reliability requirement — the same shortfall behind PJM's suspended Reliability Backstop Procurement.
Governor Sherrill declared a state of emergency on utility costs on her first day in office (January 20, 2026), directing bill credits to offset the June 2026 supply increases. Credits help households. They do not change the underlying cost of capacity.
Why Massachusetts Held Flat
Massachusetts' flat line is not a sign that its market is healthy. It is a sign that its prices were already at the ceiling.
Start with the base: Massachusetts averaged 30.21¢ in January–August 2025 — tied for the highest residential price in the continental United States. There was little room left to rise before bills became politically untenable, and the state's Basic Service procurement cycle
gave the average a timing break. Massachusetts residential supply rates reset every February 1 and August 1. The August 1, 2026 reset did raise supply prices — National Grid's Basic Service rose from 15.372¢ to 17.185¢, and Eversource's eastern Massachusetts rate to
17.323¢ — but only one month of that higher rate (August) falls inside the January–August window. Seven months of the average were still priced at the lower February–July rates.
Flat, in other words, is an artifact of timing and an already-extreme base — not a market that has found its level. Massachusetts households still pay 66% more than the national average, and the winter risk that defines the state's energy costs has not gone anywhere. January 2027 forwards at Algonquin Citygate still top $20/MMBtu, with January basis near $17.64 over Henry Hub. Last January, Winter Storm Fern drove Algonquin spot gas to $122.58/MMBtu. The flat residential average hides every bit of that volatility, because residential rates are set in six-month blocks while the wholesale market moves daily.
There is also a quieter story inside the Massachusetts number: the spread between doing nothing and shopping. Competitive suppliers are offering residential supply around 15.1¢/kWh against Basic Service at roughly 17.2–17.3¢, and municipal aggregation programs — 14 of 16 South Coast towns, for example — are charging 14.346¢ against Eversource's 17.323¢, saving roughly $17–18 a month at 600 kWh. The default is the expensive option. It usually is.
What It Means for Commercial and Industrial Buyers
Residential prices are the canary. The same cost drivers — capacity, transmission, distribution, and winter gas deliverability — flow into commercial and industrial bills through the same default-service channels.
In New Jersey, large commercial and industrial customers buy through the BGS CIEP auction, and the capacity story is identical: the $269.92 clearing price is embedded in today's rates, the $329.17 cap price for 2026/27 is already set, and the July 2026 auction cleared at the cap for 2028/29 with a 6,831 MW shortfall. The collar bought stability, not relief. Every New Jersey facility still sitting on default service is paying capacity prices that were $28.92 two years ago.
In Massachusetts, commercial buyers face the same winter basis exposure that residential rates smooth over. ISO New England's own market monitor reported summer 2026 wholesale costs of $2.52 billion, down 4% from $2.61 billion a year ago — a mild summer helped. Winter is the season that matters in New England, and the market is pricing
January Algonquin basis near $17.64 for a reason.
The lesson is the same in both states, and it is the one we keep coming back to: the regulated default path is where the increases land. In New Jersey, that means BGS rates set by an auction driven by capacity prices no governor controls. In Massachusetts, it means Basic Service rates that reset twice a year and a delivery charge that keeps climbing. The buyers who do best in both markets are the ones who get off the default timetable — shopping supply competitively, timing contracts around the auction calendar, layering hedges instead of taking a single price, and treating basis as a line item to manage
rather than a surprise to absorb.
PEM Perspective
Two states, two headlines, one underlying truth: where you live still matters enormously when it comes to electricity costs — but how quickly those costs are changing may matter just as much. New Jersey's 7.9% jump is the capacity market working its way through the bill, and the cap that slowed it down is temporary. Massachusetts' flat line is a high plateau, not a valley, and the winter basis risk underneath it has not moved at all.
For buyers in both states, the question is not whether prices will move. It is whether your contract is positioned before they do. A facility still on default service in New Jersey is paying for a capacity market that cleared nine times higher than it did two years ago. A facility on Basic Service in Massachusetts is paying a premium for the privilege of not shopping. In both cases, the fix is the same: review your supply position now, benchmark it against the market, and structure the next contract around your usage — not around the
utility's calendar.
Winter is almost here, and the market is already sending its first signals.
#PremierEnergyManagement #NewJersey #Massachusetts #ElectricityPrices #EnergyMarkets #PJM #ISONewEngland #NaturalGas #EnergyCosts
Winter is almost here...
Would you like a review of your facility's Winter Energy strategy? We are here to help!




Comments