top of page

Eight States Just Asked PJM to Hit Pause on the December Auction — and the $5–10 Billion Question Behind It

Writer: Tony Zelinski
Tony Zelinski
34 minutes ago
7 min read
Eight States Just Asked PJM to Hit Pause on the December Auction — and the $5–10 Billion Question Behind It
Eight States Just Asked PJM to Hit Pause on the December Auction — and the $5–10 Billion Question Behind It

Eight state consumer-advocate offices — including New Jersey's own Division of Rate Counsel — have asked PJM's Board of Managers to postpone the December capacity auction. Their argument is blunt: the auction as designed would force 67 million consumers to pay for data centers that may never exist. The price tag, according to PJM's own independent market monitor, is another $5 billion to $10 billion.


This is not a fringe objection. It is the market monitor's recommendation, now backed by the consumer advocates of seven states, landing three weeks before the auction opens. And for energy buyers in New Jersey and Massachusetts, the outcome will shape the capacity costs embedded in every electricity contract they sign for the rest of

the decade.


What Happened


On November 18, the consumer advocates of Ohio, Delaware, West Virginia, Maryland, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Illinois (Illinois sent two offices — the Attorney General and the Citizens Utility Board) wrote jointly to PJM's board. Their ask: direct PJM to seek

Federal Energy Regulatory Commission approval to postpone the Base Residual Auction scheduled for December 9–15, 2026, which sets capacity prices for the delivery year running June 1, 2029 through May 31, 2030.


They want the delay to last until two things happen: data-center load — "both real and speculative," in the letter's words — is removed from the load forecast, and a separate reliability backstop procurement for large loads is in place. They asked for a written answer from the board by November 23.


The letter builds on the market monitor's third-quarter State of the Market report, published November 12. Monitoring Analytics, PJM's independent market monitor, warned that the 2029/30 auction will use a load forecast that includes data centers it considers canceled or

unlikely to ever reach their projected demand. Its conclusion: the auction would clear at the maximum price and add another $5 billion to $10 billion in costs for all customers. The monitor recommended postponing the auction.


The advocates stress a point that matters: the monitor is not simply asking PJM to refresh its forecast with newer numbers. It wants a fundamental change in how forecast data-center demand is treated — so existing consumers are not required to subsidize speculative or

uncommitted load. Even if PJM's final planning parameters, published November 19, strip out canceled projects, the advocates say that would not meet the monitor's recommendation.


The Numbers Behind the Fight


To understand why $5–10 billion is credible, look at the last three auctions:


  • 2024/25: $28.92/MW-day — the last low-price year.

  • 2025/26: $269.92/MW-day, a nearly tenfold jump that landed on bills across the region.

  • 2026/27: $329.17/MW-day — the FERC-approved price cap, hit across the entire PJM footprint. Total cost: $16.1 billion, up 9.5% from $14.7 billion the year before.


The 2029/30 auction's price cap is $337.83/MW-day, with a floor of $181.91/MW-day and a forecast peak load of 171,916 MW. The monitor's case is that with speculative data-center load baked into that 171,916 MW forecast, the auction clears at the cap again — and the cap is now higher than the last one.


The cumulative picture is worse than any single auction. The monitor puts data-center-driven capacity costs at $29.4 billion across earlier auctions, and wholesale power prices up 9.8% in the first nine months of 2026. Maryland People's Counsel David Lapp put the household impact in plain terms: an on-schedule auction would keep data-center costs of

more than $10 a month — "and possibly much higher" — in rates.


New Jersey buyers should read that alongside this week's other headline: New Jersey winter electric bills rose 25.3% last winter — the steepest increase in the nation, to an average of $160 a month — while Massachusetts averaged $212 a month, up 8.1%. Capacity costs are

not an abstraction in these states. They are already the fastest-growing line on the bill.


PJM's Answer — and the Other Side


PJM is not conceding the point. Spokesman Jeffrey Shields told Utility Dive that the December auction has an established price cap that safeguards against high prices, and that postponing it this close to the auction "could destabilize the market and increase the risk of power interruptions."


The advocates answer that the delay would not disturb the cap at all, because FERC's order extending it set no condition on the auction date. In their reading, a postponed auction clears under the same cap — it just clears against a forecast that reflects real demand.


Generators are pushing back too. The Electric Power Supply Association, which represents competitive generators, argues that late rule changes and delays add risk that ultimately raises costs. A Manhattan Institute researcher made the same point: a debate over how

to charge data centers should not delay an auction three weeks out.


Both sides have a point. Delaying an auction this close to its date is disruptive, and reliability planning cannot wait forever. But the monitor's core finding is hard to dismiss: the forecast contains load from projects it judges canceled or unlikely to materialize, and every

megawatt of phantom load in the forecast is a megawatt of capacity that real customers pay for.


The Exelon Link — and the Backstop


The advocates' letter also points to Exelon's November 3 complaint at FERC (docket EL27-11), which challenges PJM's three-year-forward auction structure, partly over the same uncertainty in forecasting data-center load. Exelon's requested relief would begin with the

2030/31 delivery year, so it would not change the December auction — but it shows the same dispute is now running on two tracks at once.


The second track is the one PJM itself has already started building. Under pressure from states, federal regulators, and consumers, PJM has proposed a two-part plan for data-center demand: facilitate bilateral contracts outside the normal capacity auctions, and hold a separate reliability backstop procurement for large loads that don't have bilateral contracts. Its amended backstop filing, submitted to FERC on October 29, sets a bid window of March 1–28, 2027, with results in May.


That is exactly what the advocates are asking the board to wait for: run the backstop for the big loads, and let the main auction price capacity for the demand that is actually there. In January, the White House's National Energy Dominance Council and the governors of the PJM states signed principles saying PJM should buy capacity "only for real and verified demand." The advocates cited that principle in their letter.


What This Means for Energy Buyers


Capacity costs are the quiet half of an electricity bill. Energy gets the headlines; capacity is the charge for having generation available when the grid peaks, and it flows straight into supply contracts. When an auction clears at the cap, that cost is locked in for the full

delivery year — June 2029 through May 2030 in this case — and it shows up in every fixed-price offer a buyer evaluates from that point on.


Three things to take from this week:


  • First, the December auction is not a done deal. The board's answer is due November 23. If the board declines, Ohio and Maryland have both said they are weighing action at FERC — and PJM would need FERC approval to move the auction in any case. A delay is a live possibility, not a long shot.


  • Second, the $5–10 billion is an estimate, not a result. If the auction runs on schedule and clears at the $337.83 cap, the monitor's estimate becomes the bill. If the auction is delayed and the forecast is cleaned up, some or all of it disappears. The number to watch is not the estimate — it is the board's November 23 answer.


  • Third, this is a contracting question, not just a policy debate. Buyers with contracts renewing in 2029 or 2030 should be asking their suppliers how capacity costs for that delivery year are being priced into offers, and what happens to those offers if the auction moves. A supplier quoting capacity on a December-auction assumption is quoting a number that may not survive the month.


PEM Perspective


The capacity market was designed to buy reliability at the lowest reasonable cost. When the forecast includes demand from projects that will never plug in, the market stops doing that job — it buys capacity nobody needs, at the maximum price, and sends the bill to the

customers who were already there.


The advocates are not asking PJM to abandon the auction. They are asking it to run the auction against real demand, and to handle the speculative load through the backstop mechanism PJM itself proposed. That is a reasonable ask, and it is the same principle — pay for what is real, not what is rumored — that should govern any buyer's

procurement strategy.


For commercial and industrial buyers in New Jersey and Massachusetts, the practical move is the same as it has been all year: know what capacity is costing you, know when your contracts renew, and don't let a single auction — especially one this contested — set your price without scrutiny. If the board delays, the December numbers change. If it doesn't, the cap-clearing result the monitor predicts becomes the baseline for 2029/30 pricing. Either way, the buyers who understand their capacity exposure before the auction will negotiate from a stronger position than the ones who find it on their bill.


What to watch:


PJM's board answer, due November 23; the auction

itself, December 9–15; and any FERC filing, from either side, in the

days after the board responds.


Winter is almost here, and the capacity market is deciding what your 2029 power will cost. The time to understand your exposure is before the auction, not after the bill arrives.


Winter is almost here...

Would you like a review of your facility's Winter Energy strategy? We are here to help!



 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page